The Charlotte City Council requested that the courts dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit filed by the relatives of the young Ukrainian woman who was murdered
The Democratic City Council of Charlotte is seeking to prevent the lawsuit for wrongful death filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, the 23-year-old Ukrainian woman who was stabbed to death by an African American while traveling on the city's train system.
The local leftist government requested a Mecklenburg County judge to dismiss the case and argued that it is protected by North Carolina's governmental immunity laws.
The court filing was made on November 16 and constitutes the city's formal response to the claim brought by Zarutska's relatives.
The attack.
The lawsuit was filed in August 2026 against the City Council and the private security company Professional Security Services, whom they accuse of negligence and failing to implement sufficient measures to protect passengers.
However, the municipal Democratic administration rejected the accusations and maintained that it cannot be held responsible for the attack committed by African American killer DeCarlos Brown Jr.
According to their lawyers' arguments, the accused acted on his own and his conduct constituted an independent criminal act that "could not have been foreseen."
The city also invoked governmental immunity to defend its decisions related to limited transportation oversight, crime prevention, and poor public safety management.
One of the controversial points of the filing is related to the security measures that the family considers essential to prevent crime. The City Council acknowledged that there were no security guards inside the train car at the time of the attack and that the transportation system operates without physical access barriers.
The victim and the killer.
Despite these acknowledgments, it rejected that the absence of security personnel inside the train, the lack of access controls, or the fact that Brown had not paid for the ticket caused Zarutska's death.
The complaint from Zarutska's family
The family, for its part, argues that there were known risks in the transportation system and that implementing measures such as ticket checks, increased guard presence, surveillance, and physical barriers could have prevented the murder.
The City Council also requested that, in the event any of the claims succeed, any compensation against the city be limited to a maximum of one million dollars.
The decision is now in the hands of a judge from the Mecklenburg County Superior Court, who has yet to rule on the motion to dismiss. If the request is accepted, the Democratic city could be removed from the case.
The case is generating controversy over the responsibility of Democratic authorities in the protection of public transportation and their current efforts to avoid a trial over the security failures reported by the victim's family.